Monday, April 21, 2008

Hillary Hates Us

Hilzoy pretty much nails the problem with Hillary's anti-MoveOn rant.

    Conflating opposition to the war in Iraq with opposition to the war in Afghanistan is exactly the sort of thing that drives me up a tree when, say, Peter Beinart does it. It amounts to taking a position that a whole lot of people hold -- either opposing Clinton herself, or opposing the war in Iraq -- and conflating it with one that only a small minority of people hold, and then using that supposed "fact" to discredit your opponents -- to cast them as members of some tiny fringe that doesn't need to be taken seriously. It is what Atrios calls the "dirty f*cking hippies" argument: that people who oppose the war in Iraq, or Clinton herself, are just relics of the 1960s, or some other variant of "not serious people like us", and their views can therefore be dismissed out of hand. "MoveOn didn't even want us to go into Afghanistan. I mean, that's what we're dealing with."

    To say this about her opponents is just wrong. But to say it about the activist base of her party -- about the people who are motivated enough to show up for caucuses and participate in the electoral process -- is insane. Hillary Clinton is running for the nomination of the Democratic Party. She is trying to represent us. If she thinks that people like publius, who caucused in Texas, is worthy of contempt, or that the stunning increase in Democratic voter participation this year is not a cause for joy but a sign that the dirty f*cking hippies have taken over, why doesn't she just become a Republican? She's certainly talking like one.

1 comments:

Bill Sloat said...

Pho --

I just read and re-read what she said. I was for Obama, then drifted toward Hillary over the NAFTA/Canada stuff that took place in the days just before the Ohio primary. I am quite supportive of the military action in Afghanistan; now very doubtful and troubled by Iraq. I think those words of Hillary's about the Democratic base have moved me back to Obama. And I am thinking hard. Thanks for finding this material.